is this pic any good??? i'm only an amateur

[Guest robynsarah220]

Someone let me know if its any good?

personally i think it is but there are too many subjects in the picture and its a bit dark.

thats my opinion though!

[Guest robynsarah220]

Here's my edited version of the pic. Any better???

[Guest chriscraft]

hi

welcome to picy section,what camara did you use?/

[Guest robynsarah220]

cheap nasty digital one. not an slr or anything posh!

[SteveO]

Looks good to me but i'm no expert, just a snapper.

Regards

Steve

[Guest]

I'm a snapper as well, but I like first one best, its mean and moody.

[Guest robynsarah220]

the second one is edited and i added a film grain to it. I'll try and get some more up here

[Guest robynsarah220]

shame the wing is all blurred!! and the back ground not in focus.....

[Guest robynsarah220]

nor will pretending to be good at photography....

i'm willing to hear my faults!!!!!

[Guest]

Everyone is keeping a low profile on this one ... because the answer to your question is very subjective, and it depends on what you want the photograph for It's a nice evocative memory of a Broadland evening, which is what a lot of people are very happy to achieve with their cameras, and is a fantastic objective. If you wanted a "formal" critique of it as a shot for sale for a calendar or magazine that would be a different topic, and probably not terribly relevant! As with most things in life, it depends on context. It speaks to me of a Broadland sunset, watching the sun go down with a beer/gin and tonic. Who could ask for more?

[Guest Hank]

I prefer the first one

The second doesnt have much colour but the first has no colour except for the sun which now becomes the highlight of the photo