Back to Steve & Debs original question, do we need one of these radios? To be honest, no. By and large just toys for the boys but useful for boats with masts approaching low bridges. Mind you, some of the inane chatter can be vaguely amusing! I was, for years, an Auxiliary Coastguard and radio watches were a regular duty. Some folk seemed oblivious to the fact that the whole world and their dog could listen in to their conversations. Fishermen, when returning home, are quite good at calling up their womenfolk and telling them of their forthcoming plans in quite graphic terms, if you get my meaning! Yes, there is an entertainment value in having and using VHF, but that really is not what they are for.