The comparison was more to highlight the similar curve of degradation, the two are vastly different in size but rely on the same industry.
Its not about building houses or shopping complexes in fact quite the opposite, its about tradition buildings complimented with a little subtle modern flare, the day of the retail high street has gone, now we need the curious, the bespoke and the hospitality, the 'cafe culture' but in the uk we cannot fill our streets with tables and chair's our climate does not cater for it, out door spaces with roofed shelters work here.
Give people a reason to visit destinations rather than just hoping they come, and more importantly give people reason to want to return, its easy to get one off custom, but repeat custom its what is needed for success.
Going back to the Broadshaven, until it address' the lack of atmosphere mainly caused by its architecture I cannot seeing it ever working.